Frederick, a 54 decision in which chief justice roberts, writing for the majority, decided that a student could be punished for displaying a banner with the words bong hits 4 jesus on a public sidewalk. We asked the court to reaffirm the same freedoms that have helped us secure the rights of lgbtq students to be out at school, take a samesex date to the prom and form gaystraight. Follows the civics unit 10 plan landmark supreme court casesgoes with the unit 10 day 1 morse v frederick handoutfull disclaimer. This is a brief overview of some of the landmark cases over the past century that have addressed students rights at school. Frederick was a supreme court that addressed student speech. In the supreme court of the united states ronald s. Do school authorities violate the free speech clause of the first amendment by restricting student speech at a. Supreme court docket oct nov dec jan feb mar apr unscheduled previous terms download march 19, 2007 argument calendar pdf click here for 2005 docket many documents listed on this page are pdf files that may be viewed using adobereader.
The district court ruled in favor of morse, saying there was no constitutional violation on her part. Frederick, concerned the rights of a public school student to unfurl a banner reading bong hits 4. The court suspended him because he held up a sign that the principal interpreted as a prodrug message. Smith wigglesworths vision of an end time revival duration.
In your own words, describe the facts of the case, the issue, and the holding. He was eighteen years old and he displayed the banner bong hits 4 jesus. Supreme court on june 25, 2007, ruled 54 that alaskan school officials had not violated a students first amendment freedom of speech rights after suspending him for displaying, at a school event, a banner that was seen as promoting illegal drug use the case arose in 2002 when the torch relay in advance of the winter olympics in salt lake. Supreme court cases and decisions free speech cases and. The district court granted petitioners summary judgment, ruling that they were entitled to qualified immunity and that they had not infringed frederick s speech rights. Principal deborah morse took away the banner and suspended frederick for ten days. Bong hits 4 jesus january 24, 2002 juneau, alaska outcome the superintendent upheld the suspension cornell. Frederick audio transcription for opinion announcement june 25, 2007 in morse v. Kuhlmeier 1988 is important for both students and advisers. Student press case research journalism on the ridge. Roberts, jr first, students do not shed their first amendments rights at the schoolhouse gate. The links below will get you to the assignments for morse v frederick case opinions. Choosing a backup generator plus 3 legal house connection options transfer switch and more duration. The court will hear argument first today in case 06278, morse vs.
The event in question occurred during normal school hours and was sanctioned by morse. The principle of the school, patricia morse, felt the banner had a pro drug message and made him take it down and suspended frederick for 10 days. Topic 8 freedom of speech authorstream presentation. Learn more about this case and wamus unprecedented podcast from drexel kline. She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal. Joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school, unfurled a banner saying bong hits 4 jesus during the olympic torch relay through juneau, alaska on january 24, 2002. Frederick lies the first amendment question of whether or not schools can limit students free speech in 2002 joseph frederick, a senior at juneaudouglas high school in juneau, alaska, was suspended for displaying a banner with the phrase bong hits 4 jesus. Oyez can focus their attention to the portion of the supreme courts work that most interests them. Morse mania is a morse code tutor for the macintosh.
Morse took the case all the way to the nations highest court. Its the law articles links to articles about some of the more recent cases, anything since 2000 not all cases are there. Constitutional questions breyer, ginsburg, souter, stevens and the lower court dissented analyzing the case under tinker, the lower courts had found no disruption, and therefore no basis for discipline. Frederick cir filed an amicus brief in this important free speech case concerning the authority of school officials to punish high school students for speech they deem contrary to the mission or work of the school, including offcampus speech. Accepting that frederick acted during a schoolauthorized activity and that the banner expressed a positive sentiment about marijuana use, the court nonetheless found a first amendment violation because the school punished frederick without demonstrating that his speech threatened substantial disruption. Supreme court on june 25, 2007, ruled 54 that alaskan school officials had not violated a students first amendment freedom of speech rights after suspending him for displaying, at a school event, a banner that was seen as promoting illegal drug use. Chief justice roberts delivered the opinion of the court. The majority held that the message although cryptic was reasonably interpreted as promoting marijuana use. Established that free speech for teenagers was not as extensive as the same right for adults, and that if a student went against a schools antidrug mission, that student could be punished. The justices ruled that frederick s free speech rights were not violated by his suspension over what the majoritys written opinion called a sophomoric banner. Theyve created amazing materials for the civics curriculum. Hines, doctor of veterinary medicine, petitioner, v.
Frederick, supreme court ruled that a school could discipline a student for unfurling an offensive banner bong hits 4 jesus across the street from a school event in 1986, the supreme court ruled in bethel school district v. Morse later explained that she told frederick to take the banner down because she thought it encouraged illegal drug use, in violation of established school policy. There are suggestions below for improving the article. Deborah morse imposed a penalty upon joseph frederick and she suspended him. Joseph frederick, a student at juneaudouglas high school in juneau, alaska, displayed a banner at a high school event on which was written. If you stop a student from expressing views that advocate drug use, are you violating their right to free speech. Supreme court on june 25, 2007, ruled 54 that alaskan school officials had not violated a. May it please the court, i am shelby simmons, counsel for the petitioner, principal deborah morse. Frederick opinion of the court normal school hours. At a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking. She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the display of material that promotes the use of illegal drugs. At a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, a high school principal saw some of her students unfurl a large banner conveying a message she reasonably regarded. Audio transcription for oral argument march 19, 2007 in morse v.
The following cases are included in the powerpoint. What specific sections of the constitution were involved continue reading morse v. The ninth circuit held that principal morses actions violated the 1 st amendment and that the student could sue the principal for damages. Mac arthur pierrelouis is a family attorney in houston, tx. Morse mania morse code software practice tutor for the.
She justified her actions by citing the schools policy against the. Morse confiscated the banner and told frederick to report to her office, where she suspended him for 10 days. Once these issues have been addressed, the article can be renominated. Overriding governmental interest burning draft cards. The district court granted petitioners summary judgment, ruling that they were entitled to qualified immunity and that they had not infringed fredericks speech rights.
During the olympic torch relay through juneau, joseph frederick, a student, held up a poster at a schoolsupervised event. For the first time in nearly 20 years, the supreme court is poised to address the free speech rights of students. Frederick was suspended for 10 days because morse believed the sign was promoting the use of illegal drugs, in violation of school policy. Civil liberties and civil rights linkedin slideshare. Frederick was a social sciences and society good articles nominee, but did not meet the good article criteria at the time. The event in question occurred during normal school hours and was sanctioned by morse as an approved social event at which. The original materials from the florida supreme court website can be found under this tab. An examination of the controversial supreme court case surrounding the bong hits 4 jesus banner. A free powerpoint ppt presentation displayed as a flash slide show on id. Justice teaching lessons florida southern college in. A case in which the court found an alaska public school principal had the right to suspend a student for holding up a bong hits 4 jesus.
Frederick, concerned the rights of a public school student to unfurl a banner reading bong hits 4 jesus at a schoolsponsored event. The ultimate decision in the supreme court was a 54 vote in favor of principal deborah morse. For example, a student studying constitutional law could limit the app to only those cases that would be found in any casebook or textbook. In the crime against persons we created a powerpoint and in the powerpoint we had to choose a. Frederick, decided by the supreme court last monday, june 25.
Principal morse suspended frederick, a high school senior, for displaying a banner which read bong hits 4 jesus. On petition for writ of certiorari to the united states court of appeals. Every other hearing, from the federal district court, to the court of appeals ruled in favor the principal morse. The justice teaching center for civic learning provides a variety of lessons and activities to use in the classroom as part of your partnership. Older versions are also available for those with older operating system versions. The first link just below is for honors government scholars, while the two links below that will link to the. Mar 19, 2007 washington a high school seniors 14foot banner proclaiming bong hits 4 jesus gave the supreme court a provocative prop for a lively. Frederick, involving a high school senior from juneau, alaska, who was suspended for displaying a banner that his principal did not approve of. Mar 19, 2007 at a schoolsupervised event, joseph frederick held up a banner with the message bong hits 4 jesus, a slang reference to marijuana smoking. United states, chaplinsky v new hampshire, west virginia board of education v barnette, new york times v sullivan, united states v obrien, tinker v. Certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the ninth circuit.
Many still demand more protection of school speech. Frederick, the supreme court ruled it is not a denial of first amendment rights for school officials to censor student speech they believe encourages. As the olympic torch relay passed outside of joseph frederick s school in juneau, alaska, he unfurled a sign that read bong hits 4 jesus. Joseph frederick held up a banner that said bong hits 4 jesus at a school sponsored event. Support our response to covid19 your gift will fund our critical work to protect voting rights, demand that vulnerable people in prisons, jails and immigration detention centers be released, and fight to ensure reproductive health care remains open and accessible to all who need it. Frederick 2007 who dissented and what did they think. It also concluded that morse was not entitled to qualified immunity because frederick s right to display the banner was so clearly established that a reasonable principal in morse. Cohen v california, miller v california, texas v johnson, rav v st. In 2002, juneaudouglas high school principal deborah morse suspended joseph frederick.
In 2002, joseph fredrick held up a banner on a school field trip in juneau ak. Lambda legal filed a friendofthecourt brief in support of fredericks right to free speech. Frederick limits students freedom speech bearing news. Frederick said the banner was a nonsensical message and that he intended the banner to proclaim his right to say anything at all. Frederick 2007 summary the decision in one of the most important student speech cases to reach the court in decades came at the end of last term.
At a schoolsanctioned and schoolsupervised event, petitioner morse, the high school principal, saw students unfurl a banner stating bong hits 4 jesus. Supreme court ruled 54 that morse was not violating frederick s rights by punishing him. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. As the olympic torch relay passed outside of joseph fredericks school in juneau, alaska, he unfurled a sign that read bong hits 4 jesus. The us supreme court reversed the ninth circuit by a 54 decision ruling that school officials can prohibit students from displaying messages that promote illegal drug use. Ppt first amendment in schools powerpoint presentation. In week 3 of this course you were to read the case of morse v. Utica, there may be articles for the other cases as well thinkfirst information for dean v. Frederick syllabus first amendment by confiscating the prodrug banner and suspending frederick. Oct 06, 2014 gideon v wainwright explained in 5 minutes. Joseph frederick unfurled a homemade sign in 2002, as the olympic torch made its. Lawyer macarthur pierrelouis houston, tx attorney avvo.
Frederick to discuss a nuanced interpretation of the first amendment. Majority opinion the majority opinion was written by chief justice john g. Frederick further restricted student speech, but it didnt solve the debate. Supreme court hears bong hits 4 jesus politics nbc news. Joseph frederick p, a public school student, was suspended by the principal deborah morse d for displaying a banner on which was written bong hits 4 jesus, bong being slang for marijuana, at a school event which was covered by television. Heres a short summary for those who dont know about morse v. Constitutional law free course by frisco independent. Brutally honest valedictorian regrets being top of the class duration. This is free because it is a modified resource from. The principal, deb morse, took away the banner and suspended frederick for 10 days saying it promoted illegal drug use. Introductory materials and unit maps course curriculum. The event was scheduled to pass along a street in front of juneaudouglas high school jshs.
1386 632 699 1377 143 851 1100 660 439 1077 305 1170 660 972 312 230 199 521 583 175 640 1126 106 244 354 659 1227 249 1276 1131 468 302 440